Napalm Riot

It's a well-known fact in the world of game reviews that publishers wish to control every step of the process. They decide who receives early access to the titles, they make the rules about when the reviews can be run, and they can pick and choose which sites or magazines get the highly coveted "exclusive" review of big-name titles. What happens when a site goes against this system and runs a review before the embargo is up on a copy of the game not given to them by the publisher? In the case of Atari and a gaming site in Germany called 4players, the publisher simply sues.
Related Stories

* New Alone in the Dark may lack Home features on PS3
* This week in game releases: June 23-29
* Infogrames: Alone in the Dark to sell 3 million
* Alone in the Dark: SecuROM strikes again

The argument is that since press copies of the newest Alone in the Dark title had not been made available to the site before the retail release of the game, the site had reviewed a pirated copy of the game. Copies of the game are in fact available on P2P, but the site claims that a retail connection gave them a physical copy of the game before the release date, allowing them time to play it and review it. The site also alleges that Atari has pulled an advertising campaign in retaliation.

It's impossible to know if 4players had a legit copy or a pirated version of the game, but this shows just how broken the embargo system is for game reviews. When you receive a game to review, the first thing you know to look for is the embargo; you have to find out when the company is going to allow you to run your review. Unless you signed paperwork saying you'd hold your review until that date, there is nothing keeping you from breaking the embargo, but game companies have long memories—and they talk to each other. If you get a reputation for not honoring embargoes, you can expect to stop receiving review copies, and you may find that getting press access at shows like E3 becomes problematic.

Read more here: http://arstechnica.com/ne…egative-early-review.html